Book Review: “Damage” by Poornima Manco

42939052
Damage” by Poornima Manco

Damage is a collection of 16 fiction short stories that take place in Indian Societies, both in India and elsewhere. The overarching theme of this book is how those who cause harm to others have grown up damaged. Dark tones progress along the book, from extramarital affairs and gun violence to rape.

The book delivers what it promises. The reader is shown realistic and believable sections of Indian society as Manco writes parts of dialogues in native language[s] to make the characters as authentic as possible. While doing so, the author also embellishes the prose with rich vocabulary and fascinating images. However, stringing pretty words is not sufficient in storytelling.

I enjoyed most plots, yet they felt artificially construed. The characters did not go through sufficient development within the stores, and I felt that these characters were created to show us a story that Manco wants us to see. It was only until the last few stories that I truly enjoyed reading. My favourite was the 11th, “Palindrome”, which started, continued and ended poetically. I’d have loved the whole book to contain a similar structure in which the main premise doesn’t drown the flow of the story — especially in the cases when the story’s rushed with time jumps at every other paragraph.

Along with the previous point, the characters lacked depth. The author provides us with a description of physical appearances but fails to create personalities that would stick with the readers. Moreover, the physical descriptions of each character were freakishly objectified and sexualised. Arguably, most stories involved love affairs and sexual intimacy; but this objectification at times is described by those characters who would be children when they ‘observe’ such things.

One of my other issues with this book is its strong suit: the eloquent writing. Undoubtedly, Poornima Manco is skilful, using a varied repertoire of vocabulary. This is an unfortunate choice when this voice doesn’t suit the narrative. I found it off-putting, distancing me from the main character. Moreover, adverbs and adjectives weakened various paragraphs. In addition, I noticed a few breaks in point-of-view, but an average reader might turn a blind-eye to these.

Overall, Damage is a collection of okay stories and a few hidden gems. Although the themes are gruesome, the realism in each story comes across easily. If you can get past these few pet peeves of mine, I’m confident you’d enjoy the writing. I also think this collection would be particularly interesting to the Indian community as the subtle social criticism may be quite striking.


I received a free Review Copy from Reedsy in exchange for an honest review.


Sources and Links:

Book: Damage
Book Cover: Goodreads
You could give your support by donating to my Ko-Fi or PayPal.me

Advertisements

Book Review: The Silver Linings Playbook

I am a huge fan of the film, and having watched it numerous times, I felt it was time I read the novel that it is based upon. To my surprise, there were quite a number of differences throughout, and not just the ending. The characters not only have much more depth, but they’re presented differently and more authentic to the experience they’re put in.

The premise of the story is that Pat, who is put into a mental facility for an indeterminate amount, is taken out to live with his parents. He’s doing his best to win back his estranged wife, Nikki, who he hasn’t seen since the incident that he doesn’t remember. He works out most of the day to get back into shape and spends a lot of time reading English literature — specifically the books Nikki teaches to her students. At the same time, he does his best to win back his father’s approval and gain back a relationship with his brother Jake.

I love this book because Pat’s point-of-view is written well; we are able to understand his reasoning as much as he does, and much better than those around him. The main difference between the film and the book, without giving much spoilers, is that the film is much more based on romance, as to what I remember, where this is more personal and about Pat’s recovery. It always has been — but the book shows is much more.

Society may have a generalised view on mental health, and I think this book portrays it so realistically. A lot of the suffering may come from not from mental illness itself, but rather how others, especially close family and friends, treat others differently. One of my favourite aspects is not that Pat is mentally ill and everyone else is stable; but really, everyone has their flaws and issues. It becomes evident in Pat’s friendship with Tiffany, in which they bond in unusual activities (running all day without talking) and how they’re both treated similarly by their family. Pat’s household doesn’t come short on this aspect ­— his father avoids speaking with him and has had experience of angry outburst; his mother is constantly crying and upset. These elements are what makes living with mental health so real; they don’t necessarily need labels or stereotypical symptoms, but they interweave themselves in the intricacies of daily life and social relationships.

The story follows a similar outline to the film and is quite pleasant to follow. Reading the book, I was expecting to know the story, and I was still enjoying it on a new level. However, I discovered so many differences, especially with how the last quarter of the book progresses, that it’s almost a novel experience; I had no idea what would happen. This elevated my experience and I recommend this book to be read. There’s not much lost if you’ve previously watched the film. I’m sure I’ll keep on remembering this novel as one of my favourite stories that I’ve ever read or watched.


Sources and Links:

Book: The Silver Linings Playbook
Book Cover: Goodreads
You could give your support by donating to my Ko-Fi or PayPal.me

Book Review: The Rosie Result


Review

I’m a huge fan of the Don Tillman series, having read and loved the previous books (The Rosie Project and The Rosie Effect). Unsurprisingly, this book lived up to my high expectations. The story continues around eleven years later, with Don and Rosie’s child, Hudson, no longer a newborn.

The Rosie Result brings a fresh angle to the series, with Don Tillman now being a father facing career trouble due to public outrage. Don is seen through a lens of autism due to the particular way he does things and he’s pressured by others to identify himself as autistic. Moreover, his son is facing issues at school, with the threat of being rejecting from high school due to the frequent meltdowns.

What’s great about this book is that it provides an authentic, autistic perspective. In this case, the narrator (i.e. Don, the father) can identify with the son and understand the issues that he encounters at school. They both experience the pressure from the neurotypical majority to fit in and change their behaviour. This shifts the focus from the neurotypical perspective that autistic people are abnormal to the genuine experience of how autistic minds work, and how the neurotypical majority create a hostile environment, requiring others to fit in.

In the book, Don says something that struck me:

“Neurotypicals criticised autistic people for lacking empathy — towards them — but seldom made any effort to improve their empathy towards autistic people.”

This book celebrates neurodiversity and is a great learning tool for parents, educators, psychologists and the likes. It brings awareness that what neurotypicals is best might be counterproductive. As an autistic person, it gave me a lot to think about, to process about how frequently I feel like I don’t belong, and that after all, I am not the problem — society’s lack of flexibility is.

Apart from the autistic aspect, the story is extremely engaging, and has Don’s charm written all over it. I enjoyed it even more than the previous two books — which I had rated as five-stars each. The writing is well-researched and there are multitudes of personalities and characters that grow and change so well across time. They are quite representational and include am impeccable variety of characters, such as Gary the homeopath who refuses to immunise his children. There’s a warm sensation in how Don looks at the world and how he assumes honesty from others and adds to the narrational charm he possesses.

There are several reasons why I’d recommend this book. It’s a great fictional and literary work. The representation is genuine. Characters are well-developed. And, I believe, one doesn’t need to have read the previous two books to follow this story, although I would obviously suggest reading at least The Rosie Project as it helps us fall deeper in love with Don’s charisma.


I have received an Advanced Review Copy in exchange for an honest review. The book will be published in the UK on 4th April 2019, and can be preordered here: The Rosie Result


Sources and Links:

Book: The Rosie Result
Book Cover: Goodreads
You could give your support by donating to my Ko-Fi or PayPal.me

Book Review: The Poet X

The Poet X
by Elizabeth Acevedo

Book Review

The Poet X is an incredible book. It’s a novel told through the poems of the main character, Xiomara, a Latin-American teen living in a Harlem neighbourhood. We’re taken on a journey of coming of age. Xiomara is questioning her Catholic faith, which is very dear to her mother. She’s starting to catch feelings for a guy. Even though she’s tough on the outside, she’s mellow inside and her beautiful poetry is a testament to this, even though she doesn’t let anyone read or listen.

I have only good things to say about this book. First of all, the format is quite fresh. It’s not the first time we’re told a story through diary or journal entries, but this book takes it on a new level. The poems are given attention, they’re polished, they have form and they vary appropriately to show story and character.

Reading the poems, I’ve cried several times. The poems that touched me the most were her relationship with her mother, and how the change of faith in her religion has affected the relationship drastically. It’s as if Xiomara is actually the author and I’m reading a non-fiction poetry collection about her life. Too real, too touching. Authentic in a way I could relate to. And the way she finds a voice in her poems—it teaches us the true power of poetry and its necessity to our psyche.

There’s not enough high-praise I can do for this book. It just might be the best book I’ve read yet. I strongly recommend this; it’s quite empowering and can only imagine the strength of the impact it will have on younger people. Writers, especially poets, should not skip on reading this either. It’s the kind of book I’d reread and want to have permanently (as I do) on my shelf.


Sources & Links

Book: The Poet X
Book Cover: Goodreads
Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud
Header Photograph: Cristina Gottardi

Book Review: The Fault in Our Stars

The Fault in Our Starsfaultinourstars

Hazel is a sixteen-year-old with a terminal cancer, undergoing treatment that prolongs her life. She’s tired of going to support group whose leader is all about “living our best life, today”. In one of the sessions Augustus Waters, a teenage boy who had lost a leg but was free from cancer, joins the group. As Augustus comes closer to Hazel, she pushes him away, not wanting to scar him when she inevitably passes away.

The overall plot is decent. The author did show me well enough everyone’s conditions, their limitations in every day activities, like Augustus not being the best driver because of his leg. However, something felt quite artificial while reading. The dialogues were unusual. In a way, the dialogues converged into nihilism so often, it felt like it was a monotone author rather than the characters having their own voice.

Hazel and Augustus are sixteen-years-old, but it feels as if their minds are decades older. Their way-of-speaking and articulation is a barrier to me immersing myself in the story. And that’s a shame—I’m unable to empathise with them or their love because they are simply puzzle pieces that the author plays around to fit inside the book.

Not wanting to sound too harsh, I should be clearer. It’s not a bad novel. I managed to read through it with mild curiosity. It’s enjoyable, but at the same time, there is a lot of untapped potential. In fact, I’ve rated this 3/5 stars on Goodreads. Since this book is a best-selling novel, I’m really eager to hear feedback/opinions from my own readers, and whether you guys think differently about this.


Sources and Links:

Book: The Fault in Our Stars

Book Cover: Goodreads

Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud

Header Photograph: faultinourstarsCristina Gottardi

Book Review: Like Bees to Honey — Caroline Smailes

Like Bees to Honey (Book Cover)
Like Bees to Honey (Book Cover), by Caroline Smailes

Nina Aquilina travels back to her homeland, Malta, to visit her ageing parents who had previously disowned her. The stay turns out to be somewhat unexpected, as she finds out that Malta is where diseased spirits go to heal and move on to another stage in life. She talks with the spirits and drinks beer with Jesus while trying to find her identity and culture that she has left behind in her youth.

The story embodies Maltese culture beautifully.  Caroline Smailes immersed herself into the character and allowed the reader to experience something unique. Although Nina is Maltese, her establishing a family in England and being disowned by her parents had led to her loss in faith and culture. The re-exploration of her identity allows readers who are not familiar with Malta to be introduced to the rich culture. Dialogues include a few Maltese words, and the story occurs in historically rich locations and includes local cuisine. These are all aptly described in a way that connects you the story better.

Something I particularly liked was the rhythm of the story. It had hints of monotone and repetition, especially when describing sounds. The presentation of the book was also quite different. Although some reviewers disliked this style, I found it effective in aiding the concept of not being encapsulated by time. There’s a lack of urgency and it adds to the effect of identity diffusion. This monotony also helped me relate to Nina easier. I could focus on Nina’s depressive ambience, rather than complicated and bombastic writing.

It’s a two-edged sword almost. A technique that contributes to the magical story-telling can be interpreted as alienating writing, depending on the reader. Especially in the case of Nina, a person wouldn’t be so attentive and selfless to observe all around her, but rather focus on who is speaking, and it is a rare occasion I forgive the abundant use of dialogue tags. I am convinced that the writer did this intentionally (just a hunch).

The novel included a few chapters from the point-of-view of two spirits (or ghosts, whatever you want to call them). In the paperback version, their pages have a black border. This is a subtle difference (it is not distracting) to distinguish between Nina and the particular ghost’s point-of-view. However, their chapters did break the pace.

Personally, I really liked Tilly’s character and chapters, but, this almost had a drawback when I went back to Nina’s point-of-view. Although it was interesting, and I’d love to read a whole book from Tilly’s personality, I feel the author went too much into her life and away from Nina’s story. I didn’t particularly enjoy that dissociation.

Flavia Bellini’s part—not sure what to say about it. As a reader who was brought up in the Maltese-Catholic background, I was already quite familiar with the cultural and religious context. Thus, Flavia’s part was personally too long and somewhat boring. It’s a historic, religious story, repeated within this novel. I didn’t particularly find it useful within the story, at least not for the length that it took. That section did distract me from the main story, but perhaps it was pivotal considering Nina’s religious background and her attempt at rediscovering her identity and tracing religion along that line.

I read the book in a short span of time, which is a great sign. I’ve rated the novel 4/5 stars (I really liked it) on Goodreads. Most of my good ratings are influenced by impeccable character depth and/or outstanding writing. Like Bees to Honey is a unique work, and I judged it on a different scale, almost. Its storytelling sets it off from anything I have read previously, and that gets bonus stars on itself. I transported myself into the story quickly, empathising with Nina early on.

I even shed tears by the third chapter, and a book had never done that before. It’s a combination of great storytelling and similarities between Nina and I. The shame that Nina brought to her Catholic family for getting pregnant outside marriage is similar to what I felt when I came out as gay. Consequently, both Nina and I had lost our identities, and perhaps, this was one of the reasons I could immediately understand some of Nina’s experiences.

Overall, it was quite a pleasant read, significantly unique and deserves a place on your bookshelf (do read it with an open mind).


Sources and Links:

Book: Like Bees to Honey

Book Cover: Goodreads

Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud

Header Photograph: Cristina Gottardi

Book Review: The Rosie Effect

Descriptiontherosieeffect2.jpg

A few months into their marriage, Rosie announces her pregnancy. Don Tillman does not feel prepared for this unplanned event, and has serious doubts about his ability to be father. He embarks on a project on learning how to be a father, while simultaneously managing a social world bigger than he’s ever had. Can their marriage survive with the addition of a third person to the family?

Review

This book was another easy read after The Rosie Project. I had high praise for the first novel, and I can only give better praise to the second. I’ve read several reviews which consider this to be a disappointing sequel. I suspect that they fell in love with the ‘romantic-comedy’ feel of the first book, which is less present here. I’m a reader who fell in love with the characterisation and genuine portrayals, as you will soon read.

Don Tillman

The best thing about the first novel was Don’s character. For those who haven’t read my previous review or The Rosie Project, Don is a geneticist professor with undiagnosed Asperger’s Syndrome. His friends have become accustomed to his lack of social skills, but this often leads him into trouble with strangers, including the police and airport officials. His unique way-of-thinking is marvellous and charming (to me), and I find a home in his portrayal. Consequently, I feel the pain of his social failures and the lack of understanding the world has.

Storyline

As I’ve also said in the previous review, this series is based upon character arcs and great writing. The events that happen in this book are more interesting than the first, and once again, quite unique and pertaining to Don Tillman. The author makes us believe that some of these unusual events that wouldn’t happen to most of us, do indeed take place, because Don’s life is a predicament of unpredictability emerging from his heavily-structured life.

Relationships

This time around, the novel has juggled my emotions as if they were a clown’s toy. The Rosie and Don relationship is constantly a central relationship to the series, and it progresses to a new level with the expectation of their baby. Their family would now have to include two more relationships: Rosie-baby and Don-baby relationship, which would alter theirs. Furthermore, Gene and Claudia, friends of Don, had split and Don tries to fix their problem. Dave and Sonia, who are Don’s friends and also pregnant, struggle with their relationship and business as well. The interplay of all these relationships is done beautifully, with each person contributing different advice and experiences to the story.

Summary

An easy 5/5 stars rating. I loved this book even more than the first in the series. The portrayal of Don is believable and exquisitely exciting. There is no predictability with what will happen in the lives of Don and those around him. And to those who negatively reviewed the book and said that the novel is problematic for not clearly stating that Don is autistic, I have one thing to say. Many adults (and children) are undiagnosed, and Don is a great depiction of this, as he is not controlled by any therapy or institution to behave like neurotypical individuals.


Sources and Links:

Book: The Rosie Effect

Book Cover: Goodreads

Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud

Header Photograph: Cristina Gottardi

Book Review: Beyond Freedom, by Jennie Taylor

beyondfreedom.jpg
Beyond Freedom by Jennie Taylor

The following review contains some spoilers, especially relevant to the first book of the series, Freedom’s Fate. This review has been previously published on Steemit around two months ago, and have recently realised that I have not published it here.

Description

Beyond Freedom is the second book in a series, a sequel to the sci-fi novel Freedom’s Fate (click to read my review). The remaining crew of the ship Freedom have landed onto a moon, and they have to try and make it habitable for them. This includes finding edible food and drinks, as they have finite supplies that they brought with them. Upon exploring for resources, they meet indigenous creatures, without any knowledge of these species. An interesting adventure lies ahead.

Review

I gave this book a rating of 4/5 stars. I loved reading it, and was a great follow-up to Freedom’s Fate, but it had a very few shortcomings.

Story

The sci-fi setting is interesting, although there is a huge change between the first and second book. Whereas I was used to a structured interstellar ship, now, we find ourselves into an unknown, habitable moon, with almost no knowledge of it and its inhabitants. From a writing perspective, the writer is not limited to anything; flora, fauna, completely new ecosystem. At first I thought it was going to be a predictable story line, but it soon picked up and went into something unexpected. I really enjoyed the story, and although I felt the author was risking going into cliché plots, she did not. Yes, there are certain events that occur that seem to be “too perfect”, but sometimes these are just illusions.

Characters

We are already accustomed to most characters by the end of the first book, although some characters become more prominent in this one. I think there was a good variety of characters. I had loved the depth of personalities in the first book, and one of my favourite relationships was that between Bao and Callie. Their relationship was authentic and it was lovely to have that depth of character relationship that was not tied within the plot itself. On the other hand, I did find Callie’s constant worries about herself and Anna to be a little frustrating. This was quite a relevant theme in the first book, although it seems to be a little out of place at times.

Back to the array of personalities, Shauna’s hot-headed and impulsiveness counterbalanced Callie’s personality well. These are small things which I enjoy; diversity done well and feels authentic. Especially as the context had changed drastically, each person depends on one another more. A community always depends on teamwork, but when it becomes to a smaller community, teamwork is that much more essential to the function of the community. Thus, the mix of personalities makes the tasks of teamwork interesting, especially for a leader who needs everyone to be on board.

Society

This was a point I had done in my review for the first book as well. I find that the book can be interpreted in a critical way to modern society. This, more than anything, might be attributed to me and the way I read things, so it might not be the same for other readers, and might have not been the author’s scope.

So, apart from the main group, in the story (without giving too much), we encounter societies of other species. In a way, they can be paralleled to types of communities or societies, and I find fictional settings to relate in such way. For instance, religion has been predominant throughout human history. Having said that, it appears in many shapes and forms, and although the word ‘religion’ may signify a meaning, you will have no idea on how these species act or behave. In a way, the rituals were somewhat parallel to human forms of ritual. It worked well to give an identity and volume to the particular species, but at the same time failed my expectations of unlimited imagination and possibilities. We often say that history repeats itself; and this made me wonder whether there is a pattern that is repeatable across species, planets, universes, or whatever.

Summary

I hope to have reviewed the book well, although my tired mental activity might have impaired me in writing coherently while capturing the essence of the book. I am in love with this series, and this book was a great sequel. Two weeks ago, I let the author know some of my opinions about the book, and I am positive that some of the minor stuff might have been edited and improved by now or soon. That kind of author only makes me love their work more; because they are open to feedback and care about us readers. I would suggest that you go read the first book, and if you love that, it’s a no-brainer to read Beyond Freedom as well.

Book Review: The Crucifixion and Resurrection of Malachi the Queer, by Damian Jay Clay

Trigger Warning: This review contains elements of sexual assault, depression, suicide attempt and PTSD.

malachithequeer
Book Cover: The Crucifixion and Resurrection of Malachi the Queer by Damian Jay Clay

Description

Malachi is the son of a celebrity Baptist pastor. He’s a genius and a well-behaved Christian boy; all that his parents could ever hope for. However, he no longer believes in god and starts to realise he’s gay. When his father starts suspecting the latter, he sends Malachi to a conversion camp. Although the boy knows his sexuality cannot be changed by reason, he fears that indoctrination might change the person he is. He’d have to find out after the camp was complete.

The Realness

As the story is something a reader must experience on his own, I avoid using spoilers and will focus on other aspects. Malachi is brought to life immediately, with a well-forged character identity. The first few chapters set a clear picture of who Malachi is at home and at school. It also builds the world in which Malachi lives: school, family, religion. Apart from the characters being extremely real, the whole story almost feels like if it were non-fiction; that’s how much the author Damian Jay Clay has succeeded in making me believe this story.

Graphic and Heavy Language

The realness aspect of the story is aided heavily by graphic and emotionally-heavy language. This is especially present in episode of PTSD or sexual assault, which one may feel uncomfortable or distressed while reading. Having said that, I managed to read through the novel (an average of a chapter or two a day) without feeling distressed. I assume that this is partly due to Malachi’s perspective and his strength and resilience. Hence, the author equips the reader with the same resilient and strong mindset of the protagonist.

LGBTQ+ Youth

The book appropriately addresses the dangers that LGBTQ+ youth experience. Many kids experience physical and/or sexual abuse from relatives or religious figures because of their sexual orientation or gender expression. Moreover, this often leads to issues in mental health, such as depression, anxiety, PTSD and higher rates of self-harm and suicidal attempts. As harrowing as this sounds, the book grounds these issues in an extremely real story and humane characters.

There are two things this novel could be useful for:

  1. Teens and young adults who are going through similar issues may find a way to cope and fight back during their struggles.
  2. LGBTQ+ or ally individuals will be able to understand a reality beyond their experience. Hence, when we think of what needs to be done in the community, we can empathise and acknowledge suffering that we could currently be blind to.

Summary

This novel deserves the full five-star rating. The author has clearly researched and dove into this novel with his heart and mind and delivered an exceptional novel. The development of the story was consistently intriguing, and the characters were believable. I would recommend this book to anyone who is interested in this story or topic, but caution to put first your mental health and don’t rush through if it may seem distressing.


Sources

Book: The Crucifixion and Resurrection of Malachi the Queer

Book Cover: Goodreads

Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud

Header Photograph: Cristina Gottardi

Header Editing: Jeremy Mifsud

Book Review: Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda

Spoiler Alert: This review contains some spoilers.

Description

Simon Spier is a sixteen-year old high school student, residing in Shady Creek. Martin, a fellow classmate, tells him that he has screenshots of Simon’s email to Blue which reveal their gay identity. He blackmails Simon in the hopes of getting a date with Abby. At the threat of being outed, Simon worries about his possible relationship with Blue, while he helps out his blackmailer to avoid being outed.

The Story

The story immediately starts off with the blackmailing incident. I found this to be a little disappointing, as there was no setting depicted beforehand. I have no clue on who Simon was or what Shady Creek is about. All I know is that Simon has this secret that he is gay, and that Martin is blackmailing him. For Simon, coming out isn’t as dangerous or that big of a deal, which makes this story different than the more dramatic and cliche story-lines out there.

The rest of the story is somewhat lacklustre, remaining at a surface level. The author’s dedication to diversity, a world where of acceptance and zero-tolerance to bullying portrays a risk of a plateau. Reflecting after reading, the high-school drama (and the blackmail) seemed to be a bigger part of the story than coming out or being a relationship were.

The Trope of Avoiding Tropes

What I admired is that the author has drifted away from the usual stereotypes and clichés. Upon the first chapter, one would expect the story to be very predictable with the blackmail and rampant homophobia, but this is not the case. It’s a great way to show queer people that there are accepting families and friends, and thus it is quite representative of modern societies. It acknowledges that things are harder for some individuals. Yet, that makes the story somewhat unexciting. At the expense of avoiding certain tropes of rejection and character stereotypes, the author ends up on the other spectrum of predictability. The happy-ever-after comes way too easily with seemingly minor obstacles, and thus the ‘climax’ is barely as triumphant as it could have been.

Character Depth

As I mentioned, the story starts immediately with a changed scenario, so we are unable to know the characters beforehand. The question rises to whether it is who they are or whether this is what they are doing due to the situation. Simon, who declares himself as a nosy person, does not give us a lot of perspective of the people around him. As understanding that everyone has their secrets and their lives, it becomes a fault in that we do not really know those around him, almost as if Simon does not know them (or he is too self-centred).

Alternating Chapters

The format of the book is split into two. We get (almost) alternating chapters. The first format is the typical first-person story of Simon. The other is smaller chapters of emails from Simon to the secret identity of Blue and vice-versa. As the emails were exchanged at a slow rate (sometimes days in between), this decision felt a little off. The emails are primarily a source of romanticism and do not give us valuable information. Undeniably, the emails are cute and made me “Awhhh” a couple of times. However, I’m not too in favour of this decision, as it creates a chronological gap between the other chapters.

The secretive Blue as well, seemed to be a weak character, as once revealed, appears to be a different character to how he portrayed his personality in the emails. For Simon, it was the same Blue, but as a reader, I felt that there was a lack of consistency. Blue’s identity was mysterious for the author to be able to mislead us on who the person is; however, that cost us with the lack of excitement upon revealing who he is.

Conclusion

Being indecisive, I am giving a rate of 3.5 stars. The characters were unique and pleasant but lacked a level of depth I’m used to. The story was representative and somewhat unique, up until the cliche climax/ending. Even though the emails were cute and romantic, I would have chosen to integrate them within the other writing, to enhance the temporal effect of the emails on Simon’s life. Nonetheless, it is a pleasant read, with thousands of readers falling in love with it much more than I did. Leah on the Offbeat is a Creekwood sequel, which I am vaguely interested in, but hold myself from

reading due to not loving the author’s writing style.

Note. Whenever teenagers spoke about Tumblr as “The Tumblr”, it made me cringe. It just sounds off.

Simon vs The Homo Sapiens Agenda (Book Cover)
Simon vs The Homo Sapiens Agenda’s cover, as taken from Goodreads under the rights of fair use.

Sources

Header Photograph: Cristina Gottardi

Header Editing: Jeremy Mifsud

Book Review: Jeremy Mifsud